American Association of Law Libraries: Access to Electronic Legal Information Committee
AELIC Home

About

Committee Members

Website Evaluations

Accessibility Issues

Bibliography

Presentations

Frequently Asked Questions

Information for Committee Members

Judicial Branch Website Evaluation Criteria

Updated May 2004.

Members of the Access to Electronic Legal Information Committee have developed tailored sets of criteria for evaluating legal and government information at government web sites. The criteria sets include the "General Evaluation Criteria for All Web Sites Providing Legal Information" and four other criteria sets that provide "Evaluation Criteria Specific to Judicial,  Legislative, Executive Branch, and Local Government Web Sites."

  1. Primary Documents

    A court Website should optimally contain the full range of primary legal documents specific to that court. Ideally, keyword search capability of opinions should be available.

    1. Opinions of the court
    2. Special links to most recent or cases in the news
    3. Court rules
    4. Records/Briefs
    5. Orders
    6. Oral Arguments


  2. Secondary Documents

    A court Website should contain those secondary legal materials that assist the public with advisory materials that provide guidance in filing pleadings with the court:

    1. Court forms
    2. Court dockets
    3. Model/pattern jury instructions
    4. Standards of professional conduct
    5. Annual Report of the court
    6. Links to helpful websites, particularly links relevant to the court's jurisdiction


  3. Judicial Information

    A court Website should contain information about the judges of that specific court:

    1. Courtroom and chambers location(s)
    2. Individual judge's docket and hearings schedule
    3. Contact information for judge and chambers staff (including court bailiff/courtroom deputy)
    4. Case management procedures
    5. Judicial biographies


  4. Clerk's Office Information

    A court Website should contain information that assists the public in working with the court administratively and in locating staff that will provide guidance on filings, status, etc.

    1. Hours of operation
    2. Location (parking instructions, public transportation route information)
    3. Staff contact information (phone numbers and/or email)
    4. Fee Schedule
    5. Filing guidelines, tips
    6. Electronic filing guidelines (if E-filing available)


  5. Jury Information

    A court Website should provide information for prospective jurors with all aspects of jury duty:

    1. Place of holding court
    2. Contact information
    3. Compensation
    4. Duties/responsibilities of jurors
    5. Job protection/Request for excuse/Failure to Report

Would you like to suggest other criteria that the Committee should consider?
Please email the Committee Chairperson, Timothy Coggins at :  tcoggins@richmond.edu

 

This site has been considered and approved by the American Association of Law Libraries Executive Board.

AALLNET Home | Member Directory | Join AALL | AALL Staff
AALL Chapters | AALL Committees | AALL Special Interest Sections | AALL Products
Washington Affairs | AALLNet Site Map

Copyright 2001 American Association of Law Libraries